Social media giant plans to form measurement council and provide more third-party data verification for partners
Facebook Inc. said it has uncovered several more flawed measurements related to how consumers interact with content, raising more questions about the metrics marketers lean on to decide whether to buy ads on the social media network.
The company publicly disclosed on Wednesday that a comprehensive internal metrics audit found that discrepancies, or “bugs,” led to the undercounting or overcounting of four measurements, including the weekly and monthly reach of marketers’ posts, the number of full video views and time spent with publishers’ Instant Articles.
None of the metrics in question affect Facebook’s billing, said Mark Rabkin, vice president of Facebook’s core ads team.
This revelation comes two months after Facebook acknowledged that is had been overestimating the average viewing time for video ads on its platform for roughly two years.
- Heard on the Street: A More Vulnerable Facebook
- A Bear Signal on Facebook Shares
- Fake Content Puts Pressure on Facebook, Google (Nov. 15, 2016)
- Facebook Bans Fake News Sites From Ad Network (Nov. 14, 2016)
- Zuckerberg Defends Facebook Over Election Criticism (Nov. 14, 2016)
- Facebook Restricts Ads Targeting Ethnic Groups (Nov. 13, 2016)
That news led Facebook to take a deeper look at all of its advertising-related metrics and data.
Now, after finding more examples of data miscalculations, Facebook said it would provide additional independent review of some measurements to calm unease over the social network’s data.
The unveiling of the additional errors may trouble some advertisers and web publishers that rely on Facebook for distribution and monetization.
Several had already called for additional third-party validation of Facebook’s data.
As part of its effort to assuage advertiser concerns about the soundness of its metrics, Facebook will provide viewability data from third-party metrics companies such as Moat and Integral Ad Science for display ad campaigns. Previously, this data was limited to video campaigns.
“We are doubling down on our efforts at third-party verification,” said Carolyn Everson,Facebook’s vice president of global marketing solutions.
In addition, the social-media network said it is working with ratings firm Nielsen to count Facebook video views, including both on-demand views and live viewing, as part of Nielsen’s Digital Content Ratings metric.
Lastly, Facebook said it plans to form a Measurement Council made up of marketers and ad agency executives, and will roll out a blog to communicate more regularly on updates about measurement.
As for the newly discovered bugs, the errors apply to only four of more than 220 metrics that Facebook counts.
In one instance, Facebook found that it had been overcounting how many people were exposed to marketers’ organic posts, meaning regular posts that weren’t paid ads, because it was adding up the daily reach over certain periods without accounting for repeat visitors. The corrected metric on average will be about 33% lower for the seven-day period and 55% lower for the 28-day period, Facebook said.
In another case, Facebook found it had been undercounting how many people watch video ads to their completion.
Some people watch video ads in their entirety, but because the audio and video tracks aren’t always perfectly synced, Facebook wasn’t counting some views as completed at 100%. As a result, Facebook expects the count of completed video views to increase by 35%.
Because of another calculation error, the amount of time people spend with Instant Articles was overreported by 7% to 8% on average since August 2015, Facebook said.
“Some of [the bugs] will have a bigger impact than others,” said Mr. Rabkin. “The range of impact varies. We wanted to err on the side of fairness and transparency.”
Facebook’s efforts to fix its reputation with Madison Avenue may fall short of the demands from some ad buyers.
MORE ON MEDIA
- Online Measurement Is a Mess, Says Former Chartbeat CEO Tony Haile Nov. 16, 2016
- Media Executives Divided Over Facebook Policing Fake News Nov. 16, 2016
- AMC Networks Invests in Funny or Die Nov. 15, 2016
- GroupM Shuffles Leadership, Consolidates Groups Nov. 14, 2016
For instance, as part of the increased data verification, Facebook doesn’t plan to let ad buyers track campaigns using their own ad “tags,” or tracking code, as some have advocated.
The lack of fully independent third-party ad verification was a major sticking point following Facebook’s recent video counting mishap, particularly considering Facebook’s growing dominance in the ad world.
GroupM, the ad buying unit of WPP PLC, said it was encouraged that Facebook was clarifying metrics and seeking input. However, “today’s developments stop short of full third-party measurement which we still believe crucial to advertiser confidence in any market,” GroupM said.
One way Facebook could calm frustrated ad buyers would be to undergo an audit via the Media Rating Council, the media industry’s independent research watchdog.
Following the recent overcounting error, the Association of National Advertisers publicly advocated for an MRC audit. This is something Facebook is now considering, Ms. Everson said.
Ms. Everson said that she has been in numerous conversations with marketers and ad buyers over the past eight weeks regarding metrics, and that the company wants to demonstrate how seriously it is taking these issues.
“Clients want to have trust and confidence in their investment decisions,” she said. “My desired outcome…is that we are viewed as displaying complete transparency. We want to demonstrate our commitment.”
Write to Mike Shields at firstname.lastname@example.org
Tags: additional third-party validation of Facebook’s data, Association of National Advertisers, Bear Signal on Facebook Shares, Facebook, Facebook Hit By Election Criticism, Facebook’s video counting mishap, how consumers interact, independent review, Integral Ad Science, Mark Rabkin, Miscalculated Metrics, Moat, Nielsen’s Digital Content Ratings, Online Measurement Is a Mess, overestimating the average viewing time, social media, third-party data verification, translating numbers into meaning, vice president of Facebook’s core ads team, Zuckerberg, Zuckerberg Defends Facebook Over Election Criticism