Posts Tagged ‘Ng Eng Hen’

Asean and China committed to code of conduct for South China Sea disputes

February 18, 2018

Image may contain: 6 people, people sitting, table and indoor

Minister for Defence Dr Ng Eng Hen speaks at the 54th Munich Security Conference in Munich, Germany.PHOTO: MINISTRY OF DEFENCE

SINGAPORE – China and Asean are committed to completing code of conduct guidelines to handle disputes in the South China Sea, said Defence Minister Ng Eng Hen on Saturday (Feb 17).

Dr Ng told a maritime security roundtable at the Munich Security Conference in Germany that one aspect of China’s interest in the island chains in the South China Sea is they present potential encirclement against it.

The approach of Asean member states to these issues has been a “pragmatic one”, said Dr Ng, noting that the Declaration on the Conduct of Parties in the South China Sea, which Asean and China signed in 2002, took more than five years.

“This frames our expectations for the (code of conduct),” he said.

“In the meantime, the Asean Defence Ministers Meeting has worked hard to produce consensus on practical measures that prevent mishaps and miscalculations, or if there are,to de-escalate issues.”

He noted that there have been at least 38 reported small-scale incidents between claimant states’ ship since 2013, many of which involved fishing vessels that were eventually resolved peacefully.

Dr Ng said the Republic was glad to see that foreign affairs agencies had operationalised their hotline to respond to maritime emergencies, and that defence agencies in the region had also launched a similar direct communications infrastructure.

Dr Ng said Singapore is also pleased that the Code for Unplanned Encounters at Sea (CUES) had been expanded to all ADMM-Plus countries in November last year (2017).

ADMM-Plus includes the 10 Asean states as well as eight other countries – Australia, China, India, Japan, New Zealand, South Korea, Russia and the United States.

Singapore, the Asean Chair this year (2018), hopes to develop guidelines for encounters between regional military aircraft, he said, adding that multilateral undertakings, such as the Asean-China Maritime Exercise 2018, can “enhance practical cooperation and build confidence”.

Noting that an estimated one-third of all global shipping passes through the South China Sea, Dr Ng said: “All countries have recognised the critical need for peace and stability in these waters.”

Best keyword for search:


US reaffirmed commitment to Asia-Pacific region and bilateral defence ties with Singapore: Ng Eng Hen

April 6, 2017


SD Mattis meets with Singapore’s Minister of Defence Ng Eng Hen

US Defence Secretary James Mattis and Singapore’s  Ng Eng Hen at the Pentagon, in Washington, DC. PHOTO: AFP

SINGAPORE – United States Defence Secretary James Mattis has reaffirmed the US commitment to the Asia-Pacific region and expressed a desire to deepen bilateral defence ties with Singapore, said Defence Minister Ng Eng Hen.

He also revealed in a Facebook posting on Thursday (April 6) morning that Mr Mattis will be attending the Shangri-La Dialogue in Singapore, an annual security dialogue that is usually held in late May and often features top brass military and defence personnel.

Dr Ng, who is making a working visit to the US, met Mr Mattis at the Pentagon on Wednesday (US time), and described their meeting as “warm and productive”.

“We discussed common security challenges including the threat of terrorism and ways to deal with them. I look forward to returning the warm hospitality when Secretary Mattis attends the Shangri-La Dialogue in June this year,” wrote Dr Ng.

According to a transcript of an interview with Channel NewsAsia in Washington DC, Dr Ng described Mr Mattis, a former Marine Corps general, as someone who has strategies and plans, and vast experience in the US military.

“He gave a reassuring calm, and in his words, he’s now become the ‘Secretary of Reassurance’. So I was very happy with the outcome of that,” said Dr Ng.

“I think it bodes well from the security point, America’s commitment to the region, and not only commitment to the region, but commitment towards Asia-Pacific’s stability… There is much reassurance and confidence that Secretary Mattis is there.”

Dr Ng added that both countries remain committed to the enhanced Defence Cooperation Agreement, signed in 2015, which will further collaboration in new areas such as humanitarian assistance and disaster relief, cyber defence, biosecurity and public communications.

Singapore also remains committed to facilitating the use of Changi Naval Base and its air bases by American forces, said Dr Ng.

He said the purpose of his trip from Sunday to Wednesday (April 2 to 5) was to get a better feel of how to engage the US as there have been “several levels of uncertainty, unpredictability, new administration” under President Donald Trump since Mr Trump took office on Jan 20.

“We thought the best way to do that is to meet the individuals, the ambassadors, and we lined up a significant number of calls with old friends of Singapore who understand the politics, who understand the history of Singapore and relations with the US, and understand our region,” said Dr Ng.

He said it has been a very useful trip,  calling it not only a voyage of discovery, but also one of reassurance and reaffirmation by many strong friends and supporters of Singapore in Washington, “who have given us very good guide posts and who also gave us strong assurance that you can call on them if need be”.

Asked about the upcoming Mar-a-Lago Summit meeting between US President Donald Trump and Chinese President Xi Jinping in the US, Dr Ng said it is a “good development” that both leaders are meeting, as it is better for both countries to be cooperating than to be in an antagonistic relationship.

He said Singapore believes it would be healthy for the US and China to agree to avoid trade wars and to help both sides grow economically.

“Because from Singapore’s perspective, we benefit whenever global trade goes up. And, simplistically, if there are protectionist measures from any one country, retaliation, the effect is, as we’ve known from past experience is that global trade just goes down,” added Dr Ng.

China Warns Singapore To Be Cautious in its Handling of the Detention of Military Vehicles Issue in Hong Kong — Stresses Importance of One-China Principle

January 9, 2017

BEIJING – China has called on Singapore to be cautious in its handling of the detention of the nine Singapore Armed Forces (SAF) Terrex infantry carriers in Hong Kong, adding that the incident was being handled in accordance with the law, the South China Morning Post reported on Monday (Jan 9).

“I hope the relevant parties can be cautious in their remarks and actions,” foreign ministry spokesman Lu Kang said at a ministry briefing.

“I want to stress that China hopes other nations, including Singapore, follow the one-China principle,” he was quoted saying. “This is the foundation for bilateral ties between China and any other nation. I hope the relevant parties can follow the laws of Hong Kong, China,” he added.

 Image may contain: outdoor
Singapore’s mililitary vehicles, wrapped in green, detained in Hong Kong by China

His comments came after Singapore’s Defence Minister Ng Eng Hen on Monday said the detention of the vehicles did not comply with international law.

He added that Singapore looks forward to the Terrexes being returned.

 Image may contain: outdoor

Speaking in parliament, Dr Ng explained that the vehicles are the property of the Singapore Government and protected by international law.

Under the principle of sovereign immunity, property belonging to a country cannot be seized or forfeited. This principle is well established under international law and also the law of Hong Kong, a Special Administrative Region of China, Dr Ng said.

“Accordingly, the Singapore Government has asserted our sovereign rights over the SAF’s Terrexes,” Dr Ng said.

The nine armoured vehicles were seized by Hong Kong Customs on Nov 23 when they were in transit on their way back from a military exercise in Taiwan.



Parliament: Detention of Terrexes against international law, Singapore looks forward to their return, says Ng Eng Hen


The detention of the nine Singapore Armed Forces (SAF) Terrex infantry carriers in Hong Kong does not comply with international or Hong Kong law, said Defence Minister Ng Eng Hen.PHOTO: MINDEF

SINGAPORE – The detention of the nine Singapore Armed Forces (SAF) Terrex infantry carriers in Hong Kong does not comply with international or Hong Kong law, Defence Minister Ng Eng Hen told Parliament on Monday (Jan 9).

And Singapore looks forward to the Terrexes being returned, he said.

Dr Ng explained that the vehicles are the property of the Singapore Government and protected by international law. Under the principle of sovereign immunity, property belonging to a country cannot be seized or forfeited. This principle is well established under international law and also the law of Hong Kong, a Special Administrative Region of China, Dr Ng said.

Singapore has informed Hong Kong several times over the last two months that the Terrexes belong to the Singapore Government and are therefore immune from any measures of constraint, he said.

Singapore’s military vehicles seized in Hong Kong on Nov. 24.  Photographer: Kin Cheung/AP Photo

Prime Minister Lee Hsien Loong has also written to Hong Kong Chief Executive Leung Chun Ying on the matter, he added.

The Hong Kong authorities have responded that investigations are ongoing and will take some time to be completed, Dr Ng said.

Singapore welcomes this response, he added.

“Adherence to the rule of law has been the fundamental basis for peace and stability for the last half century in Asia. It has enabled countries both large and small to build trust and confidence in one another, cooperate and prosper together,” he said.

Image may contain: outdoor and nature

Singapore Armed Forces (SAF) Terrex infantry carriers

The nine armoured vehicles were seized by Hong Kong Customs on Nov 23 when they were in transit on their way back from a military exercise in Taiwan.

Representatives of the shipping company APL had held three meetings with Hong Kong authorities but no formal reasons were given for detaining the Terrexes.

Dr Ng said APL’s compliance with the rules of the Hong Kong port is a matter between APL and Hong Kong authorities. But that dispute should not affect Singapore’s legal position and rights with regard to the Terrexes, he said.

He also reiterated that no military secrets have been compromised as the Terrexes were being used for training and did not contain sensitive equipment.

Following this episode, the SAF has reviewed its shipping procedures comprehensively to “reduce the risk of SAF equipment being taken hostage en route”.

It currently does not ship all equipment directly from point-to-point as this will cost three to four times more and add several hundred million dollars to the Defence Ministry’s annual budget. Neither does the Singapore Navy have transport ships with the scale and capability to handle all the shipping logistics the SAF needs.


Existing commercial shipping arrangements have allowed the SAF to ship equipment safely and economically without any significant incidents over the last 30 years, he said.

But there are exceptions, such as when advanced weapon and sensor systems are transported, he said. In those special cases, the SAF may charter a whole ship, mandate direct shipping, or deploy protection forces. However, the Terrexes do not fall in this category, he said.

Going forward, the SAF is considering other options, such as housing the equipment overseas to avoid shipping altogether. The Navy’s Landing Ship Tanks, currently its largest multi-purpose and transport ships, are also due for replacement. The SAF will study if they should be replaced by ships of larger capacity, he said.

Singapore “Learning A Lesson” After China’s Seizure of Armoured Vehicles

December 30, 2016

Ng Eng Hen also says without elaborating that the Singapore city state has changed its practices to protect its assets

By Shirley Zhao
South China Morning Post

Friday, December 30, 2016, 8:24 p.m.

The Singapore military had learned a lesson from the seizure of its armoured vehicles by the Hong Kong authorities and had changed its practices to protect its assets, the country’s defence minister said on Friday in a Facebook post.

In the post, titled 2016 – A Look Back, Ng Eng Hen described the episode as “a low point in 2016 from the defence perspective”.

“The [Singapore armed forces] will learn from this episode and has already changed its practices to better protect our assets,” Ng said, without revealing details.

“But all of us are of course upset that the Terrexes, our property, have not been returned to Singapore.”

Ng said the Singapore government had been working “at all levels” to bring the vehicles back “quietly and out of the limelight where it is more effective”.

Ng added that he would disclose more details during the next parliamentary sitting.

The nine armoured vehicles, which are being kept at the customs cargo examination facility in Tuen Mun, were found by Hong Kong customs on November 23 in 12 containers which were on their way to Singapore from the Taiwanese port of Kaohsiung without the required permits.

 Some of the armoured vehicles seized at the Kwai Chung container terminal. Photo: Sam Tsang

The vehicles, which were not “specifically” declared in the cargo manifest, had been used in a military exercise in Taiwan. It was Hong Kong’s biggest seizure of “strategic commodities” in two decades.

Ng called on the military not to lose focus or “allow this one issue to dominate all else”. He also urged fellow Singaporeans not to lose confidence in the country’s sovereignty.

“We are a sovereign and independent country, and we will chart our own future,” he said.

Ng reaffirmed that the country’s relations with others such as the United States, China and India remained strong and healthy.

“We may not see eye to eye on every issue, but that is the norm of bilateral relations between any two independent and sovereign nations,” he said.

“More importantly, with these countries, both sides value the mutual benefits that arise from strong bilateral ties and want to enhance these ties, not make them worse.”

Singapore was rebuked by Beijing for maintaining military ties with Taiwan, which Beijing considers a breakaway province.

In response to the city state’s demand for an explanation, Beijing reiterated on December 7 its call for Singapore to respect the one-China policy and abide by Hong Kong law.


China’s rise cannot be contained: Singapore defence minister

December 5, 2016

SINGAPORE: The US presence in the Asia-Pacific should not be for the sole purpose of containing China, either perceived or otherwise, Singapore Defence Minister Ng Eng Hen said during a panel discussion at the Reagan National Defense Forum on Sunday (Dec 4).

“It is neither possible nor strategically necessary to contain China’s rise … China is now an integral leader of global systems of trade, finance and security. It is clear that China needs the world as much as the world needs China, and I think this interdependence will grow, not diminish,” he said at the forum in Simi Valley, California, attended by US Secretary of Defense Ashton Carter, foreign defence ministers and members of the US Congress.

He added that the rise of China, India and ASEAN are a “virtuous outcome” of the US foreign and defence policies over the last seven decades. “That very fact alone validates the US foreign and defence policies in Asia over the last few decades. But I think this success brings a suite of new challenges as we contemplate US foreign policy moving forward,” Dr Ng said.

Asked about potential collaboration between the incoming Donald Trump administration and Taiwan, in the wake of a phone call between the US president-elect and Taiwan President Tsai Ing-wen, Dr Ng said it was not Singapore’s place to second-guess on the reason for the call.

“The president-elect’s administration team followed up after the phone call to say that they adhere to the one-China policy, as does Singapore and we are very careful and in fact, constructive,” Dr Ng said, pointing to instances where Singapore helped advance the one-China policy, such as hosting the Wang-Koo talks in 1993, the 1992 One Consensus meeting and the meeting between Chinese President Xi Jinping and then Taiwanese leader Ma Ying-jeou.

Said the defence minister: “I think there are a lot of benefits of a strong China; being able to provide opportunities for both US and other countries in the world, and I think that there are many areas that you can focus on that are productive.”

Dr Ng said that he does not believe, even with any new administration, that the US would reduce its presence in the Asia-Pacific region.

“The US’ presence in the Asia-Pacific region based predominantly on security is unidimensional and structurally brittle… The US needs a multifaceted relationship with countries in Asia,” he said. “Singapore looks forward to working with the new administration to continue to allow the US to be a stabilising force in the Asia-Pacific region.”

China has harsh Words for Singapore Over Armored Troop Carriers and Taiwan

November 29, 2016

By Associated Press

BEIJING — A Chinese state newspaper on Tuesday criticized Singapore over the Southeast Asian city-state’s military training with self-governing Taiwan, following the impounding of nine Singaporean infantry fighting vehicles transiting through Hong Kong.

The Communist Party-run Global Times said in an editorial Tuesday that Singapore was responsible for the incident, but gave no details about what laws or regulations have been broken by the shipping of the armored vehicles from Taiwan. The vehicles were being sent to Singapore from Kaohsiung, in southern Taiwan, after a military exercise there, when they were seized on Wednesday by Hong Kong.

The editorial said China has long opposed all forms of military cooperation between other countries and Taiwan, which Beijing claims as a breakaway province to be reunited with by force if necessary.

“China opposes the outside world having any form of military cooperation or exchange with Taiwan,” the paper said. “Singapore, a state that has diplomatic relations with China, should be cautious in this regard.”

Singapore’s defense minister, Ng Eng Hen, said Tuesday that the city-state supports the “one-China” principle — Beijing’s view that the mainland and Taiwan are part of a single Chinese nation — and that Singapore is open about its overseas training arrangements.

Singapore and Taiwan have a longstanding military relationship that began in the 1970s and involves Taiwan being used as grounds for Singaporean infantry training.

“Any training matters between us and other countries are bilateral, and we should not unnecessarily, until the facts come out, muddle the picture and impute various motives,” he said.

Ng said Singapore “plays a positive role in cross-strait relations, and we will continue to do so,” citing as an example the city-state’s hosting of a historic meeting last year between Chinese President Xi Jinping and Taiwan’s then-president, Ma Ying-jeou.

On Monday, a Chinese foreign ministry spokesman said that Beijing has lodged a protest with Singapore following the seizure of the vehicles. Geng Shuang reiterated China’s opposition to military and other exchanges between Taiwan and the countries China has ties with.

“We urge the Singaporean government to stay committed to the one-China principle,” Geng said at a regular briefing.

Last week, Singapore’s defense ministry sent a team to Hong Kong to ensure the security of the eight-wheeled Singapore-made Terrex infantry carrier vehicles that were held by Hong Kong customs on Wednesday. It said the vehicles were not carrying ammunition or sensitive equipment and that the team would “assess the situation.”

Singapore’s army chief, Maj. Gen. Melvyn Ong, said Tuesday that the vehicles had been shipped commercially and the military was still attempting to ascertain the reason for the detainment.

Hong Kong’s South China Morning Post newspaper has said Singaporean authorities would need to contact China’s foreign ministry to get the vehicles back. The militaries of Taiwan and Singapore have long trained together, much to the irritation of Beijing.

The seizure also comes amid Chinese displeasure over Singapore’s calls for China to heed international rulings over territorial claims in the South China Sea, which Beijing says belongs to it almost in its entirety. China says international law has no jurisdiction over the matter.

Some experts have speculated that China would use the seized military shipment to pressure Singapore to adopt a friendlier stance toward China on the dispute.


China Using Its State Run Media To Battle Singapore Into Submission — Part of China’s South China Sea and Asia Dominance Plan?

October 2, 2016

By Peh Shing Huei

South China Morning Post

It is tempting to want to ignore the Global Times. The Chinese tabloid publishes content that is rude, crass and often skinny on facts.

But in the crowded and cutthroat scene of China’s media, it stands out for its success and popularity, built on the back of nationalistic coverage that at times borders on warmongering.

Sometimes, it reads like a daily newspaper edited by a bunch of Chinese Donald Trumps.

Yet, its value rests precisely in its loutish ways. It offers the outside world a glimpse of what the Chinese government is actually thinking, but unable or unwilling to say, at least not in such insulting ways.

And given the growing importance of Beijing, this peek into the dark side is precious.

The paper’s long-time editor-in-chief Hu Xijin said in an interview last month he was close to the security and diplomatic circles of the Chinese Communist Party (CCP). They shared his paper’s editorial stance, he claimed.

Hu Xijin, chief editor of Global Times. Photo: Simon Song

“They can’t speak wilfully, but I can,” he said.

It pays to take Global Times, which is published by the CCP’s mouthpiece, the People’s Daily, seriously.

Its ongoing spat with the Singapore government is instructive.

Blow-by-blow account of the China-Singapore spat over Global Times’ South China Sea report

On September 21, the newspaper carried an article saying that Singapore had raised the issue of the disputed South China Sea at the Non-Aligned Movement (NAM) Summit held in Venezuela on September 18.

Global Times added that Singapore wanted to include an international tribunal’s ruling on the waterway, which was in favour of the Philippines, in the summit’s final document.

Singapore’s ambassador to China, Stanley Loh, rejected the tabloid’s report in an open letter, saying it was “false and unfounded”.

Singaporean ambassador to China Stanley Loh rejected the Global Times report as ‘false and unfounded’. Photo: AFP

Within hours, Hu came out to stand by his paper’s report. Then, the Chinese government came out in support of Global Times.

When a Chinese foreign ministry spokesman was asked at a regular media briefing about the tiff between Global Times and Singapore, he blamed an unspecified “individual nation” for insisting on including South China Sea issues in the NAM document.

‘Global Times didn’t have journalists at summit’, says Singapore ambassador as row escalates over South China Sea report

Clearly, Hu’s boast of being the voice of the Chinese government was not an empty one.

Global Times may be the bad and hawkish cop, but its messages are a transmission from within the heart of CCP power.

The choice of Global Times as its vehicle usually comes down to two reasons, domestic and foreign.

First, and most importantly, the newspaper’s popularity allows the CCP’s message to reach as many Chinese as possible.

The paper’s Chinese-language website reaches 15 million visitors daily. That is almost three times the size of Singapore’s population.

Chinese newspaper Global Times blasted over editorial on Donald Trump and poll on unifying Taiwan by force

The belligerent tone of the paper appeals to a growing home base of young nationalists, which are referred to as xiao fen hong or little pinks.

This plays into the nationalist posture of the CCP, a position that has gained greater prominence since the financial crisis of 2008 and even more so since Xi Jinping ( 習近平 ) took over the party in 2012.

The concept of the China Dream rests on restoring China to its deserved place at the top of the world and Global Times gives vent to such aspirations.

A US Navy crewman views a computer screen showing Chinese construction on the reclaimed land of Fiery Cross Reef in the disputed Spratly Islands in the South China Sea. Photo: Reuters

Very often, this means mocking, scolding and insulting other countries. Which brings us to the second reason.

The Global Times is noticed around the world. While the paper is often lampooned overseas, foreign media pay close attention to its stories.

For the CCP, it is no use blasting other countries unless the recipient gets the message.

In that way, Global Times can be, in a sense, fair. It directs its vitriol at almost every country and territory. The top three are usually the United States, Japan and the pro-independence camp of Taiwan.

Is the Global Times really China’s official mouthpiece when it comes to criticising Hong Kong?

Next up, the rest of the world takes turns to feel the brunt of Beijing’s wrath. Last month, for instance, an editorial lambasted Australia for its support of The Hague tribunal’s ruling on the South China Sea.

“If Australia steps into the South China Sea waters, it will be an ideal target for China to warn and strike,” the Global Times threatened.

Late last year, the newspaper referred to Australia’s air operations in Southeast Asia and said “it would be a shame if one day a plane fell from the sky and it happened to be Australian”.

For Singapore, the current dispute is not the first time it has been on the receiving end of Global Times’ fire.

Former Singapore Prime Minister Lee Kuan Yew – criticised as ‘ungrateful’ by the Global Times. Photo: AFP

In 2009, former leader Lee Kuan Yew asked the US to increase its presence in Asia so as “to strike a balance”. The Chinese tabloid, citing netizens, criticised Lee as a political animal who was ungrateful to China.

Through these news stories, Beijing aims to influence, scare and bully foreign states into submission.

Such are the intentions of the latest Global Times’ reports. They are designed to frighten Singapore into, at the very least, silence on the South China Sea.

As Singapore is the country coordinator of Asean-China dialogue until mid-2018, it can expect such Chinese pressure to continue, led more often than not, by Global Times.

Visit us on Facebook:

Related on Peace and Freedom:

 (Maybe soon the Philippines)

Duterte ‘flips the bird’ at the EU during a speech televised on state

   (From July 12, 2016)

Above Chinese chart shows China’s “Nine Dash Line.” China says it owns all ocean territory north of the Nine Dash Line. There is no international legal precedent for this claim.  On July 12, 2016, the Permanent Court of Arbitration in The Hague said this claim by China was not valid.

Below related through the South China Morning Post and The Straits Times:


The writer is author of ‘When the Party Ends: China’s Leaps and Stumbles after the Beijing Olympics’, a winner of the Singapore Literature Prize in 2016. He was the former China bureau chief for The Straits Times


Practical ways needed to defuse incidents in the South China Sea, Singapore’s defence chief Ng Eng Hen says

October 1, 2016

Mechanisms must be in place to prevent non-military confrontations in the disputed sea, Ng says

South China Morning Post

Saturday, October 1, 2016, 6:21 p.m.

Countries need to look for practical ways to defuse incidents in the South China Sea, where China is pitted against smaller neighbours in multiple disputes over islands, Singapore’s defence minister said.

Ng Eng Hen told reporters on Friday on the sidelines of a meeting in Hawaii that incidents may not necessarily involve military ships. He noted navies have established protocols for when they encounter each other at sea.

Instead, confrontations may develop between fishing vessels or other civilian ships, the defence minister said.

Defence ministers from the Association of Southeast Asian Nations (Asean) and US Defence Secretary Ash Carter talked at their Hawaii meeting about ways to prevent such incidents from escalating, Ng said.

Our main interest is, either with or without a ruling, how do you make sure the region is still stable and to make sure you actually have mechanisms to prevent any escalations

His remarks came amid an escalating spat between China and Singapore over its supposed insistence on including Philippines’ position on the an international arbitration on claims in the South China Sea during the Non-Aligned Movement summit held in Venezuela last month.

Prominent defence adviser last week accused Singapore of playing an active role in turning the South China Sea row into an international issue in recent years and said Beijing should impose sanctions and retaliate against Singapore to make the city-state “pay the price for seriously damaging China’s interests”.

“It’s inevitable for China to strike back … Since Singapore has gone thus far, we have got to do something, be it retaliation or sanction. We must express our discontent,” Professor Jin Yinan told China National Radio on Thursday.

 Professor Jin Yinan

Singapore does not have any claims to disputed islands, but Ng said it’s interested in the issue because the South China Sea is a major shipping route and many economies depend on it.

China claims virtually the entire South China Sea as its own, citing historical reasons. That has pitted it against the Philippines, Vietnam, Malaysia and Brunei, all members of Asean.

China has recently developed shoals and coral reefs into seven islands with massive land reclamation work. Some of the islands have airstrips capable of handling military aircraft.

In July, an international arbitration tribunal ruled against China’s claims, saying they were illegal. Beijing has rejected the ruling and continued its activities.

Ng said the tribunal’s ruling is law, but there are “practical concerns” to consider.

“For Singapore, a non-claimant sate, our main interest is, either with or without a ruling, how do you make sure the region is still stable and to make sure you actually have mechanisms to prevent any escalations?” he said.

Carter told reporters he and his counterparts discussed improving coordination and cooperation between their militaries to keep the region’s waterways open. He said he asked the heads of the US Navy and US Coast Guard to hold a meeting with Asean partners next year to share their best practices for maritime security.



Reef debris after destruction by a Chinese super dredge

 (This    article has links to several  others related to environmental issues in the South China Sea).

A green sea turtle is seen off the coast of Oahu, Hawaii.

A green sea turtle.(Reuters)

 (Includes Obama creates largest ocean reserve, takes heat for new federal decrees)

 (Has links to many related conservation and environmental articles)

 (Rupert Wingfield-Hayes reports)

Chinese coast guard ship

 (August 25, 2016)

 (Contains links to several related articles)

An elderly Vietnamese protester holds a placard during an anti-China protest in front of the Chinese consulate in the financial district of Manila on May 16, 2014. Several hundred Filipino and Vietnamese protesters united in a march in the Philippine capital on May 16, demanding that China stop oil drilling in disputed South China Sea waters. Many Vietnamese remain uneasy with China in the South china sea till this day.  AFP PHOTO/TED ALJIBE (Photo credit should read TED ALJIBE/AFP/Getty Images)


South China Sea: Association of Southeast Asian Nations Defense Ministers Talk About The Issues Surrounding The Sea Stand-Off

October 1, 2016


U.S. Secretary of Defense Ash Carter, seated at table background center right, gives his opening remarks for the Association of Southeast Asian Nations (ASEAN) defense ministers meeting in Ko Olina, Hawaii, on Friday, Sept. 30, 2016. (AP Photo/Eugene Tanner)  (The Associated Press)

Oct 1, 2016, 12:38 AM ET

The Associated Press

Singapore’s defense minister says countries need to look for practical ways to defuse incidents in the South China Sea.

China is pitted against smaller neighbors in multiple disputes over islands in South China Sea waters crucial for global commerce. The area is also rich in fish and potential oil and gas reserves.

Singapore Defense Minister Ng Eng Hen told reporters Friday on the sidelines of a meeting in Hawaii that incidents may not necessarily involve military ships. He noted navies have established protocols for when they encounter each other at sea.

Instead, he says confrontations may develop between fishing vessels or other civilian ships.

Ng says Association of Southeast Asian Nation defense ministers and U.S. Defense Secretary Ash Carter talked at their Hawaii meeting about ways to prevent incidents from escalating.


Pentagon chief reassures Asean ministers over future US commitments

KO OLINA, United States (AFP) – Pentagon chief Ashton Carter met South-east Asian defence ministers on Friday (Sept 30) to discuss regional security issues and reassure them that America’s “rebalance” to Asia will continue under the next US administration.

The rebalance – or “pivot,” as it is sometimes called – has been a cornerstone of President Barack Obama’s foreign policy, with a shifting of focus away from the Middle East and toward the Asia-Pacific region.

In opening remarks at an informal summit in Hawaii, Carter told defence ministers that the US would reaffirm its commitment to strengthen cooperation on the shared security challenges in the region, including the return of hundreds of Islamic militants from Iraq and Syria.

“And we’ll make plans to further catalyse the Asia-Pacific’s principled and inclusive security network,” he said.

Key among these is China’s growing reach across the South China Sea.

Beijing has in recent years rapidly expanded its physical presence in the strategically vital waterway, turning small maritime features, islets and reefs into much larger islands capable of holding military facilities.

Carter, who was expected to speak to the press later on Friday, has repeatedly stressed that the US military will ignore Beijing’s contentious South China Sea claims, and keep operating in waters and airspace surrounding the islands.

“The United States would like to help all our nations see more, share more, and do more to keep South-east Asia’s vital waterways open and secure,” Carter said.

A senior US defence official, speaking on condition of anonymity, said he was confident America would retain its Asia focus whatever the result of November’s presidential election.

“We’ve got a good thing going,” he said.

“There are a lot of opportunities left over. And we want to make sure that our position in the region is solid for the next president.”

The Pentagon chief was due to meet privately with all 10 defence ministers, including the Philippines’ Delfin Lorenzana.

The dialog comes after Philippine President Rodrigo Duterte this week vowed to end joint military exercises with the US.

The firebrand leader’s comments were just the latest in a string of attacks against America. He has called Obama a “son of a w***e” and extended overtures to China, potentially upsetting a strong US-Philippine alliance dating back more than 60 years.

Duterte won elections in May in a landslide after a campaign dominated by his pledge to eradicate drugs in society by killing tens of thousands of people.

On Friday, he drew parallels between his campaign to wipe out the drug problem and Adolf Hitler’s genocidal drive, saying he’d be “happy” to slaughter millions of drug addicts.


Defense Secretary Ash Carter: US to ‘sharpen military edge’ in Asia

(CNN)The US will “sharpen our military edge” in the face of Chinese territorial expansionism and other regional threats as it embarks on the next phase of its pivot to Asia, the US defense secretary said Thursday.

The “rebalance” to the Asia-Pacific region would ensure that the US “remains the region’s strongest military and security partner of choice,” Pentagon chief Ash Carter told US Navy sailors in a speech aboard the aircraft carrier USS Carl Vinson in San Diego.
The declaration comes as China, the region’s other superpower, continues to make neighbors nervous by unilaterally developing what most analysts agree are military installations on disputed reefs in the South China Sea, one of the world’s busiest shipping channels.
In a post on his Facebook page Carter called the region “the most consequential region for America’s future” and said that a strong US military presence there was of “fundamental strategic importance to our country.”
In the speech Carter said that the focus on the region, which will come with a raft of military investment, will see strike capability and support beefed up as well as “large new investments” in cyber, electronic warfare, and space capabilities.
Carter also said the Pentagon also has “a few more surprises” in “‘leap-ahead investments,” which he did not elaborate on.

Increasingly belligerent neighbors


Carter said that the region was experiencing “historic change” where “China is rising, which is fine, but behaving aggressively, which is not.”
He also alluded to the military’s strengthening of deterrent and defensive forces in the face of North Korea’s “continued nuclear and missile provocations.”

Show of force in the South China Sea

Along with expanding territorial claims by building on disputed territories, China is also developing its cyber-espionage capabilities, and in the past two years has been accused of hacking into a number of US government and private business databases.
“China has been developing its capabilities within the PLA for a number of years, going back at least a decade. And their capabilities have now also been brought together into a single, strategic organization that is essentially a new branch of the military,” Bryce Boland, Asia-Pacific CTO of FireEye, a cybersecurity firm, told CNN.
China has all along denied the allegations of state-sponsored hacking.
The other main regional security threat which Carter pointed to was the increasing likelihood of a nuclearized North Korea. Military analysts have detected geological evidence of what they see as successful nuclear tests by the reclusive regime, which also periodically tests delivery systems.

North Korea shows off its air force

Key ally called into question

The speech came shortly after Philippines President Rodrigo Duterte asserted that the upcoming US-Philippines military drills would be the last joint drills that his country would take part in, calling into question the commitment of one of the US’ most stalwart regional allies.
Speaking to members of the Filipino community in the Vietnamese capital of Hanoi Wednesday evening, he said that he would look to expand his country’s alliances.
“I will visit China. I will open the door for everyone. I will go to Russia,” he said. “I’m serving notice now to the U.S.: I will maintain the alliance, but I will establish new alliances.
“I serve notice to you now that this will be the last joint military exercise with U.S. Jointly, Philippines, US, last one.”

Who is Rodrigo Duterte?

The two countries are scheduled to hold amphibious landing exercises from October 4th to the 12th.
Denying a rift, Carter said Thursday that the decades-old US alliance with the Southeast Asian nation was “ironclad.”
“Through the landmark Enhanced Defense Cooperation Agreement, or EDCA, the United States is supporting the modernization of the Philippine Armed Forces,” he said.
US State Department spokesman John Kirby said on Wednesday “there has been no official rendering of a decision of that sort to the US government,” but deferred the matter to the US Department of Defense.
The Philippines Defense Ministry said Defense Minister Delfin Lorenzana will speak with Duterte to “further clarification and guidance” about this comments, the official Philippines News Agency (PNA) reported.
Includes videos:

Shangri-La Dialogue: Singapore calls for close cooperation among countries to fight ‘gathering storm’ of terrorism in region — Invites Chinese Defense Minister To Next Meeting

June 5, 2016


“War against terrorism is not a war against Islam.”

Singapore Defence Minister Ng Eng Hen said a “gathering storm” of terrorism has real potential to destabilise the region as he called for close cooperation among countries to fight the threat. ST PHOTO: LIM YAOHUI

SINGAPORE – Defence Minister Ng Eng Hen said on Sunday (June 5) a “gathering storm” of terrorism has real potential to destabilise the region, as he called for close cooperation among countries to fight the threat.

“Terrorists have capitalised on existing smuggling routes to move people and arms in the region that include Southern Philippines, Indonesia, Malaysia and Singapore,” Dr Ng said in an address to defence ministers, officials and scholars from 35 countries at the annual Shangri-La Dialogue security forum.

He noted that the four South-east Asian nations have suffered terror attacks or foiled terror plans in recent years, adding: “The threat will grow if terrorist groups become more organised to mount sophisticated, large-scale attacks with deadlier weapons.

“This gathering storm has the real potential to destabilise this region, if not tackled decisively and together.”

He suggested that countries combine their resources for anti-extremism operations, citing proposed patrols in the Sulu Sea, in south-western Philippines, by Malaysia, Indonesia and the Philippines to counteract maritime terrorism and smuggling as one such initiative.

And last month, he noted, some 3500 troops, 18 naval vessels, 25 aircraft and 40 Special Forces teams from 18 countries including the US, China, India and Japan participated in the Asean-led ADMM-Plus Maritime Security and Counter-Terrorism Exercise in Brunei, the South China Sea and Singapore.

“Security forces, including militaries of individual countries, will have to combat terrorism rigorously…Collectively, we must work closely together to build up joint responses, and strengthen intelligence, surveillance and reconnaissance efforts,” said Dr Ng.

He noted that while the religious pretext of terrorism has not changed, the security situation in the region has evolved since the inaugural Shangri-La Dialogue in 2002, characterised by a deeper and stronger under-current of extremism spearheaded by the Islamic State in Iraq and Syria (ISIS), said Dr Ng.

“In the past three years alone, ISIS has recruited more sympathisers and operatives in Asean than Al-Qaeda did in the last decade, with more than a thousand fighters in Iraq and Syria,” said Dr Ng.

“Returned fighters have linked up among themselves through their networks and declared their collective goal to establish a caliphate, motivated by, in Mr Lee’s words, ‘a deeply-felt sense of Islamic brotherhood that transcends ethnicity and national boundaries’ and ‘a shared ideology of universal jihad’,” said Dr Ng, quoting late Singapore senior statesman Lee Kuan Yew’s speech in 2002 at the first edition of the Shangri-La Dialogue, organised by the International Institute for Strategic Studies (IISS) and the Singapore Government.

But Dr Ng stressed that the war on terror is not a war on Islam.

“Mr Lee reminded then that ‘it is necessary to emphasise that the war against terrorism is not a war against Islam’…This battle is against terrorists groups that “have hijacked Islam as their driving force and have given it a virulent twist… [We] must support tolerant non-militant Muslims so that they will prevail,” he said.

The minister was speaking on the final day of the three-day forum, which has been dominated by the South China Sea territorial spat between China and four Asean countries: Vietnam, the Philippines, Malaysia and Brunei.

Tension has been rising over China’s reclamation works on disputed reefs  in the waterway, which hosts a vital global shipping route. Manila has taken China’s claim to the Permanent Court of Arbitration (PCA) in The Hague and a verdict is expected to be out some time in June – but Beijing has said it will not recognised the ruling.

US Defence Secretary Ashton Carter and his counterparts from Britain, France, Canada, and India have all weighed in on the dispute at the forum. In speech after speech, they have called for China to respect international laws and freedom of navigation and overflight in the South China Sea.

Dr Carter warned that China is erecting a “Great Wall of self-isolation” and said the US will stand with its allies in the region to ensure freedom of navigation and overflight in the South China Sea.

China’s representative at the Dialogue, Admiral Sun Jianguo, has hit back at the criticisms, saying that China respects international laws and is merely upholding its sovereignty in the South China Sea. He also slammed the US, allies with the Philippines, of double standards and irresponsible behaviour in the waterway.

Dr Ng said of the dispute: “I think all of us are conscious that more is at stake than disputed rocks or islands. As Mr Lee observed in his 2002 speech – ‘the competition for economic and diplomatic influence has started’”.

The minister said China has “participated fully” in the regional security architecture, in response to a comment by a Chinese military delegate that it is “dominated by the US and its alliances”.

“The Chinese question that the security architecture is not inclusive…is somewhat puzzling,” said Dr Ng.

Referring to Asean defence ministers’ informal meeting with their Chinese counterpart, General Chang Wanquan, in Laos last month, he added: “[Asean defence ministers] recently met in Laos, with just one plus partner, and that was the Chinese minister Chang.

“[The Chinese delegate]asked how we can make it more inclusive. I’m a practical man, I would like to invite Minister Chang [to the Shangri-La Dialogue]. Please extend our invitiation to Minister Chang.”




United States Navy EP-3E ARIES II incident with China 2001 — note the damage to the nose of the aircraft. The Chinese pilot was killed.



 (Links to several related articles)